Could Daylen Lile be the Washington Nationals version of this five time All Star?

In the second half of the season, Daylen Lile was a breakout star for the Washington Nationals. His smooth stroke and aggression on the bases made him a fan favorite in DC. He brought back memories of other Nats pure hitters like Daniel Murphy and Howie Kendrick. However, the one comparison that comes up the most is Michael Brantley.

This comparison just feels so natural. Lile and Brantley even look fairly similar. The Baseball Unstitched podcast made a great twitter thread on Lile which I would implore all of you to read. They discuss his game and that comparison.

While they were the last ones to make that Brantley comparison, they certainly were not the first. There was even some buzz about the comparison all the way back in 2023, when Lile was just an inexperienced Minor Leaguer. We made the comparison in an article in September. Fangraphs also brought up the name in their article on Lile. 

So why does this comparison make so much sense? For Nationals fans, Michael Brantley is probably best remembered for being the guy who made the last out for the Astros in the 2019 World Series. He chased a Daniel Hudson slider that ended the series and put the Nats on the mountain top.

Well, Brantley was much more than just that guy who struck out to end the World Series. In fact, striking out Brantley was a rare feat. For his career, Michael Brantley only struck out 10.7% of the time. While Lile is a great contact hitter, he will always probably strike out a little bit more than Brantley. Last season, Lile struck out 16% of the time.

Brantley and Lile are the same style of hitter though. Both are hit over power profiles, but have enough juice to hit for some power. Brantley hit 20 home runs twice and hit at least 15 four times. However, the hit tool was the real star of the show here. He was a .298 career hitter, and flirted with .300 most years he was healthy. Brantley also made five All-Star teams in his career.

That is a high bar for Lile to clear, but he has the potential to be that kind of player. As we saw in the second half, Lile is a special player when he is on a heater. He was the NL Player of the Month in September and was the Nats best player in the second half of the season.

For the season, Lile hit .299 with an .845 OPS in 91 games. That is very Michael Brantley type production. Both even have a similar defensive profile, at least right now. Brantley was not a great defender in the corner outfield spots, and neither was Lile in his first season. Lile is a better athlete than Brantley was, so he has more defensive upside.

The comparisons are not just on the stat sheet though. Their swings are also very similar. Both have simple and smooth left handed swings that are very visually appealing. They make hitting look so easy. When you see their swings side by side, it is so easy to see the comparison.

Their Baseball Savant pages also closely resemble each other. Both have very high expected batting averages and low whiff rates. They both also have a knack for finding the sweet spot. Neither have elite, or even average exit velocity or barrel rate numbers, but those numbers aren’t terrible either. Here is a comparison between 2019 Brantley and 2025 Lile.

The Nats did not have many success stories in 2025. There is a reason that the manager and GM were both fired midseason. However, Lile was the biggest find of the year. He went from a solid prospect fighting for a spot in a crowded outfield picture to a player who could have All-Star games in his future.

I am looking forward to seeing what Lile can do in 2026. On the offensive side of the ball, there does not seem to be a ton of development required. Those contact skills should give him a strong floor. For Lile, the next step will be to improve his defense and turn that speed into more steals.

Lile is a player that I am incredibly high on entering 2026. He can be that Michael Brantley style hitter who can be an All-Star level contributor. It has been a while since the Nats have had someone who makes hitting look so easy. The power hitters are cool, but I love watching pure hitters like Daylen Lile and Michael Brantley.