2025 OTB Staff Football Score Predictions: Ohio

Rutgers Football is set to kick off the 2025 season against Ohio on Thursday, August 28. As is tradition at On The Banks, the staff will make score predictions and provide some context as to why they think that way.

Andrew Rice

Ohio is no slouch of a team. Last season, Ohio won the MAC championship and took home a victory over Jax State in the Cure Bowl. The Bobcats have a decent amount of playmakers, especially when it comes to the offensive side of the ball. Rutgers is also ushering in a defense that has a lot of new faces. The Scarlet Knights could initially have some trouble reigning in players such as quarterback Parker Navarro, who have a versatile skill set. That’s why it is hard to imagine the Knights pinching a shutout. As the game goes on, however, Rutgers’ defense should adjust and tighten up fast. On the flip side, Rutgers’ offense became much more potent in the offseason, and it will be looking to flex its muscles for the first time this season. The Ohio defense will struggle to keep the Rutgers offense in check, especially in the passing game, which will be too much for the Bobcats to handle.

Rutgers 35, Ohio 14

Arnav Sarkar

Both programs are looking to build off successful 2024 seasons, with Ohio coming in as defending MAC Champions and the Scarlet Knights rising in the Big Ten. The Bobcats have made some big changes, particularly on the offensive and defensive lines. Rutgers has stocked up on talent in the transfer portal, mostly on the defense, while adding a few pieces on offense that could have big impacts as well. The surprise here may be that the offenses rule the day. Although Rutgers and Ohio are known for their defenses, there are a lot more unknowns this year, while the offenses bring back relative continuity. The game is close for the first half, with Parker Navarro dazzling with his legs and scoring a rushing touchdown, but in the second half, the Rutgers offensive line wears down the Bobcats’ front seven, while Eric O’Neill and Bradley Weaver combine on the edges to slow down the Ohio attack. Rutgers stretches its lead in the fourth quarter and covers the spread to start 2025.

Rutgers 38, Ohio 20

Amar Shah

While many are quick to pencil in Rutgers as the obvious favorite, this matchup with Ohio has all the signs of an early-season trap. The Bobcats return a steady offensive line and a backfield capable of grinding down defenses, while Rutgers is still searching for consistency in the passing game. If Ohio sustains long drives and forces Rutgers into third-and-long situations, the Knights’ defense may tire quicker than expected. Rutgers’ edge talent on paper is undeniable, but that hasn’t always translated into dominant performances in games like this. Rutgers may have the advantage in athleticism, but recent history has shown that “should win” games don’t always play out according to the script in Piscataway. This one feels like a grinder that stays close into the fourth quarter, where the Bobcats’ discipline proves maturity. I see Ohio capitalizing on late mistakes to pull off a shocking win, leaving Rutgers fans to question whether the program is truly ready to turn the corner.

Ohio 24, Rutgers20

Greg Patuto

Rutgers Football is officially back. SHI Stadium will be home for the Scarlet Knights and fans alike for the first three weeks of the season against non-conference competition. Let’s remember, Rutgers has not lost a game outside of the Big Ten since Greg Schiano’s return in 2020. This year, the slate is a bit light as well. Rutgers should be halfway to bowl season heading into Week 4. But for now, let’s focus on Ohio.

The Scarlet Knights begin the season against the reigning MAC champions and are two-score favorites. The Bobcats surprised last season after having low expectations. Parker Navarro returns as a true dual-threat after rushing for over 1,000 yards last season. The top running back also returns after one year at Minnesota, as Sieh Bangura led Ohio in rushing in 2022-23. The offensive line is also full of All-MAC contenders.

But this is the Big Ten. Rutgers has plenty of continuity on offense, including a strong offensive line. The trenches lean RU. Defensively, Rutgers should be better than last season, led by the ability to stop the run. This is not a case on whether Rutgers will win the game but for all of you gamblers out there, will they cover the number? Rutgers might be tested a bit early but expect the team to roll in the second half. 

Rutgers 38, Ohio 17

Francis Hearne

The Ohio Bobcats are coming to the Banks for the season opener and they are bringing MACtion with them! They may not be a Power 4 school, but this is not just an easy tune up game. The Bobcats are the defending MAC champions, and boast a talented team led by QB Parker Navarro. He could take advantage of some inexperience early, as there is a lot of turnover on our Scarlet Knights defense. However, we have our own talented QB returning in Athan Kaliakmanis, who got hot down the stretch last year. I expect him to pick up where he left off, and put up some points today. There will be instances when Rutgers will have to outscore opponents to win games this year, and this will be one of those instances. Ohio scores late to cover, but Rutgers handles business in the second half and walks away with a convincing win. 

Rutgers 31- Ohio 20